Learn English – Ambiguity of “Lindsey told Jessica that she had cancer”

ambiguitymeaning-in-context

Lindsey told Jessica that she had cancer.

Who had cancer? Is there any rule in English to claim it definitely?

Best Answer

This sentence is syntactically correct but semantically ambiguous. One may rewrite it as

Lindsey told Jessica that the former had cancer

to mean that Lindsey had cancer or

Lindsey told Jessica that the latter had cancer

to mean that Jessica had cancer.

Related Topic