Learn English – Ambiguity when a sentence contains multiple possessive pronouns

ambiguitypossessivespronouns

I have a question related to another one that I have asked.

In the following sentence, whose father is being referenced?

Billy’s friend and his father were there.

In the following re-structured sentence, whose friend is being referenced?

Billy’s father and his friend were there.

Clearly, there is ambiguity about the second (or subsequent) nouns. Is there a better way to structure such sentences to remove the ambiguity?

Best Answer

There's always going to be some ambiguity, but I believe that

Billy's friend and his father were there.

is talking about the friend's father; to refer instead to Billy's father, you'd need to remove the "his":

Billy's friend and father were there.


Similarly for the other way around:

Billy's father and his friend were there.

is probably talking about the father's friend, while

Billy's father and friend were there.

is talking about Billy's friend.


To remove all ambiguity, you're gonna need to rewrite things.

Billy's friend was there, and Billy's father arrived eventually, too.

Related Topic