Learn English – Answering past simple question with past continuous

grammaticalitypast-tenseprogressive-aspecttenses

For example,

— What did you do yesterday?
— I was working.

I presume this is not grammatically correct; however, I often reply in this way (I'm English). Also vice versa: "What were you doing yesterday?" — "I worked."

Does it matter?

Best Answer

I was working is certainly a grammatical answer to the question, but whether you say that or I worked depends on the relationship between the speakers, what has gone on previously in the conversation and on what impression you’re trying to give.

If you are asked What were you doing yesterday? or What did you do yesterday? you won’t often reply I was working or I worked. What were you doing yesterday?, for example, can imply a suspicion, or even an accusation. In that case, the reply might well be What do you mean? I wasn’t doing anything yesterday. Similarly, if you’re asked What did you do yesterday? you might reply Um, let me see. First I went to buy a newspaper, then I took the dog for a walk . . .

There can be no single answer to a question like this. Context determines everything.

Related Topic