Learn English – Are regional accents disappearing

accent

Maybe this fits better on Skeptics @ SE?


There is an idea that is frequently seen that states that regional accents are disappearing:

Multiculturalism and globalization often get blamed as the culprit for why accents are disappearing. Digital media and Hollywood, in a similar vein, are also often accused – saying that people all end up with "TV accents."

Is there any proof that regional accents are actually disappearing?

Best Answer

There are two questions here, one about the phenomenon, is it actually the case that regional accents are disappearing, and the other, what is the cause of such disappearance.

It is incontrovertible that accents (and entire languages) are disappearing. The articles you give links to refer to scientific articles that show that fewer and fewer people are speaking like their grandparents and more likely to speak the standard accent. There are many ways to show that an accent is going away but the simplest is simply a single point of many possible, the loss of post-vocalic 'r' in England.

loss of 'r'

From 'Why r is not always pronounced in England'.

This picture shows the accents with 'r' in England, in the 1950's on the left and the 2000's on the right. There is a noticeable loss of people who don't drop the 'r'. A way to describe this is that the regional accents in England are becoming less distinct which is to say disappearing. Surely this is only one specific phenomenon, but it is one of many. There may still currently be a West Country pirate-like accent with its strong r's, but fewer and fewer people are speaking like that. Similarly, but in the other direction on the other side of the Atlantic, Boston or New York area or Southern accents which were traditionally r-less, are more likely to pronounce all their r's.

But this all shows that there is evidence that some features are being lost in a very general sense. There's also incontrovertible evidence that full languages, not just minor variants, are going extinct now around the world. So maybe you're asking if, specifically for English, whether of the the many labeled varieties out there in the US and Canada, UK, Australia, and other places, if any of those have just ... gone away. Surely, Geordie and Scouse and West Country and Estuary are all still around (and from movies and TV seem to all be going strong). And Saturday Night Live seems to be the place to do previously unnoteworthy accents of California and Philadelphia. On the other hand, I've noticed that people from the Southern US on TV interviews tend to surprisingly not 'have' an accent (regular people, not politicians). What I'm saying with all this is that it is unclear if the named varieties are being washed away, or if their distinctions are being encouraged, if non-standard varieties are losing speakers or gaining. That, as John Lawler hinted at in one of his comments, would take a lot more comprehensive research.


As to why any of this may (or may not) be happening though, that is a different matter. (note that the link I gave is titled 'Why' but there is only description in the text, little causal analysis).

One thing that is sure is that populations that are nearby and speak with each other tend to share language features, even if they are from entirely historically different speech populations (see Sprachbund). So it is almost boring to explain loss of distinctions, and eventually loss of accents (and even entire languages) by appealing to mass communication and globalization. The socially more prestige accents tend to hang around longer than the low prestige varieties.

Related Topic