Learn English – Can an inanimate object “claim” to do something? Like a car that “claims” 45 mpg

animacydirect-objects

Excited to find this website!

Is it incorrect to say that a "dietary supplement claims to treat" a condition, or that a car "claims to get 40 mpg"?

I thought that as these are inanimate objects, you would need to say "a supplement with claims to treat…" or a "the manufacturer claims the car gets 45 mpg…" but I hear this phrase frequently, where an object "claims" something. Which is correct?

Thanks!

Best Answer

The usual subject of 'claim' would indeed reference an agent. However, it is not a vast step from

Dietitians claim that co-enzyme 534, found in aardvark milk, makes waists hairier.

to

This article / magazine claims that co-enzyme 534, found in aardvark milk, makes waists hairier.

(short for the authors / editors of this article / magazine claim that co-enzyme 534, found in aardvark milk, makes waists hairier.)

and thence to

'Cozy 534 claims that its aardvark milk extracts make waists hairier'.

It's a fairly common type of idiom, a type of personification.

Related Topic