Learn English – Do you want choice A or B? Yes!– Is it wrong to answer with a yes when given two options

word-choice

If someone asks

Would you prefer to go shopping or go out to eat?

and receives the response

Yes

the response is ambiguous.

You cannot deduce which choice the responder has chosen because they haven't responded with one of the options.

Is there a rule that dictates which choice to assume the responder has made?

Best Answer

The circumstances might show which option 'yes' was answering, but otherwise you're right, it is ambiguous. In practice, it's most unlikely that any conversation would proceed along those exact lines.