I have the following sentence:
An uncommitted player reacts to different alliance types the same.
I may as well say “…in the same way” but want to keep it short if possible.
Is this a correct use of "same" as an adverb? I have checked several dictionaries. For example, the Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary & Thesaurus defines "same" as:
the same in the same way
An example sentence in the cited dictionary entry is
We treat all our children the same.
Would this be the same usage as my sentence?
Best Answer
Same is one of the most common words in the English language. It has been long used as an adjective, a pronoun or quasi-determiner, or even as a noun proper. But being roped into use as an adverb is now fairly rare in today’s literature, and is almost only ever used to mark rustic or uneducated speech. You probably should not do that.
I’m afraid that the referenced learner’s dictionary has compressed matters down so far as to leave you with a misrepresentation. It is not possible for a multiword phrase to “be” a part of speech like a noun, verb, adjective, or adverb. When we write:
Then your subject and your object, respectively “the man” and “the dog”, are not themselves nouns the way man and dog alone are. Rather, they are noun phrases, which have their own anatomies and anomalies. Here you know you have a noun phrase because of the definite article the preceding both nouns. You also know you have a noun phrase because only noun phrases can serve as subjects and objects.
Now let’s expand our sentence:
We’ve created a compound direct object by connecting the dog and the cat using a coördinating conjunction, and then we’ve added a prepositional phrase at the very end. That “at the same time bit there at the end is neither a noun or a verb nor an adjective or an adverb. It’s a prepositional phrase composed of the preposition the and the noun phrase the same time. In that noun phrase, the is a definite article, same is an adjective, and time is a noun. The entire prepositional phrase is an adverbial modifier of the predicate. But it isn’t an adverb, and it contains no adverbs within it, either.
Prepositional phrases are a type of syntactic constituent that can be used in the same way that you can use a modifying adjective or adverb.
Notice how there I’m using the preposition on followed by a noun phrase. It is a property of noun phrases in English that they can sometimes be used as modifying phrases despite having no connecting preposition. For example, here we can delete the preposition with no change in meaning:
That’s what’s going on with your example:
That’s not an adverb: it’s a noun phrase being used as an adverbial modifier of the predicate.
Here’s something that looks the same as your example, but isn’t. When someone says:
That one isn’t a modifier, though. That’s a substantive use because it’s the object. The word same itself is probably best thought of as a sort of pronoun that originated as a nominalized adjective meaning same thing. We make pronouns like this a lot in English, like when we talk about the other meaning a person. It is rather rare but possible to use same in this way without the article, or with actual nominal inflection into the plural. Here’s one of each:
That first example from Fowler still shows up from time to time in legal language, but it’s not very well thought of. The second example is a highly specialized use you’ll rarely come across.
Just as we can omit the defined article from “the same” in select substantive uses, we can also do so when using it as an an adverbial modifying phrase. Doing so is more common than the strange-sounding examples I just provided, but it remains little done in literature, with most modern examples considered to be representative of dialect, illiterate, or jocular speech.
When you use the noun phrase “the same” as an adverbial modifying phrase, it mean “in the same manner”. Here are some examples of that from the OED over the past century and a half or so:
Those examples of same without a definite article really are places where it’s an adverb. They’re also considered ‘sloppy’ speech, not something educated speakers say, deliberately used that way to convey that point. The same thing happens in the phrase “same like” where it means ‘just like’:
Another rare adverbial use is the little-seen compound same-ways:
You’re safest using same with the if you’re going to use it adverbially:
But be again warned that this is now rare in literary use. A more carefully worded version of that might be:
That said, I can find little fault in examples where “the same” is used to mean the opposite of differently:
The OED still thinks that flavor doesn’t show up much in literature any longer.