Grammaticality – Inversion with ‘Many Times’ at the Beginning of a Sentence

adverbsgrammaticalitysentence-startssubject-verb-inversionword-order

I am having a discussion with my friend. I said, "Many times I have seen him washing his car." He says it should be, "Many times have I seen him washing his car. Much like "Often do I see him", and not "Often I see him."

While I agree with him on 'often,' I am skeptical about 'many times.' I hope somebody can help.

Best Answer

Subject-Auxiliary Inversion (with Do-Support) only happens with some adverbs.
Most adverbs don't indulge.
In particular, neither

  • *Often do I see him
    nor

  • *Many times have I seen him

are normal colloquial American English.

Adverbs can appear almost anywhere in a sentence, especially its beginning and end
(though different types of adverbs have different affordances),
and they rarely affect the word order of the rest of the sentence, no matter where they wind up.

One place where this does happen, though, is with negative adverbs;
but only with certain kinds of negative adverbs. So,

  • Rarely do we see him around here any more
    and
  • At no time did he break a window.

are OK (though they seem rather old-fashioned to some),
but

  • *For no reason did he break a window
    and
  • *With no tools did he open a window

are ungrammatical with inversion, though they're fine without it.

Related Topic