Learn English – “Ironic” vs. “ironical”

adjectivesic-icalmeaningsuffixesword-choice

Being that this highly related question primarily asked whether ironical is actually a word (and if it is used regionally), I'm interested to know whether there is a difference between it and ironic and what that difference might be.

@steven_desu touched on it in his comment, but I'd like to see a more complete answer to the difference between the two words (if any).
Are they completely interchangeable?
Is one more appropriate in certain situations?

Best Answer

Given these definitions:

ironic:

  1. containing or exemplifying irony
  2. ironical
  3. coincidental; unexpected

ironical:

  1. pertaining to, of the nature of, exhibiting, or characterized by irony or mockery
  2. using or prone to irony

The only difference I could plausibly assert is that ironical means it uses irony, where ironic means it is an example of irony. That is, this conclusion of this book is ironic. This ironical book is a good, fun read. This ironical author is one of my favorites.

Parenthetically speaking, the inclusion of ironical in the definition of ironic makes sense in this interpretation because an example of irony must by definition use irony.