Learn English – It was the best decision I have / had ever made

grammar

I'm a little bit confused about the grammar used in the following two sentences:

1.) (…) looking back at it, it was the best decision I have ever made
2.) (…) looking back at it, it was the best decision I had ever made

I personally would choose the former one simply due to the reason that it sounds more natural to me! However, I have heard using native speakers (England) the second form as well!
I'm not sure now if that's just bad grammar on their part or if it's actually grammatically correct!

Thank you in advance

Best Answer

The past perfect ("had made") talks about completed action in past time from some past reference point. So I would say "I had made a lot of bad decisions before I joined Alcoholics Anonymous." All those bad choices happened before I joined AA.

The present perfect ("have made") talks about completed action in past time as recorded from right now. So I would say "Joining AA was the best decision I have ever made." That covers any decision up to the present.

For a helpful timeline chart depicting the meaning of English tenses go here.

Related Topic