Learn English – Much and many: the opposite of less – fewer debate

differencesusage

This morning, I corrected my little son on his use of much.

I don't have much Star Wars guys.

He seems to use this word quite frequently in place of many, although he doesn't often use many in place of much.

As I reflected on the general rule – much for continuous and many for discrete – I thought about how it's the same rule that I use for less or fewer.

Now there is an interminable debate over the distinction of less and fewer, which it seems boils down to less is always fine, and so I wonder if there is the same debate for their opposites (though I've never heard of it).

How often is much substituted for many? Is it often enough to be considered acceptable usage?

Best Answer

The Grammarist hints at this 'ungrammatical' usage. It appears it may appeal to young people, probably because of usage, for instance, in rap/hip hop lyrics:

Much vs many:

  • There is little controversy around the many-much distinction, and it is borne out with only rare exceptions. You might occasionally encounter a much dollars or a much people, but few English speakers use such constructions out of habit.

  • The distinction can be tricky in a few rare instances.

    • For example, while many thanks is more common than much thanks, the latter appears fairly often because we can think of this thanks as a mass noun (synonymous with gratitude) that takes a plural form by convention. Of course we can also think of thanks as an abbreviation of the plural noun thank-yous, in which case many is appropriate.

    • And then there are singular mass nouns that sound plural. Kudos, for one, is a mass noun that happens to end in s, so the phrase many kudos is more common (on the web) than much kudos even though the latter is more logical.

Related Topic