I'm interested in the difference between the idea of ritual versus supersition. As an example of my struggle, let's say that someone has a behavior whereby: if they enter a house in one door they have to exit through that same door.
Let's also say that it was their grandmother's idea, and that they follow it still today, even though they don't know why. That they are anxious about it, and if someone visits, they will gently request that the visitor follows these rules.
Is this superstitious or ritualistic behavior, and why is it either?
Best Answer
Ritual and superstition do not mean the same thing.
To complete your example, let's say they believe that if you do not leave through the same door, you will suffer bad luck.
Another example:
Another example:
The BBQ can be argued to be a ritual. However, there is no superstition involved here. No one expects negative consequences from failing to show up at the BBQ. They just like attending it.
To summarize:
An example of a ritual that is not a superstition, is the habit of sports games to start by singing the national anthem.
There is no superstition about singing the national anthem (or failing to do so). It's just a tradition that is being continued.
As the grandchild sticks to doing this; it is a ritual. It is repetitive behavior that the person chooses to repeat.
Assuming the grandchild has no idea why the grandmother did it, then it cannot be called a superstition. At best, you could call it a tradition (conscious mimicking of the grandmother), or learned behavior (subconscious mimicking of the grandmother, by virtue of never having considered not doing so).
To slightly elaborate:
If the grandchild does not know the reason why it is done; there's no reason for the grandchild to expect other people to also do it.
I think the grandchild can only ask this of other people because they believe failing to do so will bring unwanted consequences (which means they must be aware of the superstition)