Learn English – say “What’s the sense of (something)”

Here's my opinion of your alternatives.

1. "because" is your best choice for clear, correct, unambiguous communication, especially if you want to be understood easily by other non-native speakers.

2. "since" is acceptable, although it makes your statement ambiguous; the second meaning would be that statement A became true at the time that statement B became true. Example: "I study more often since I enrolled in class" conveys that when you enrolled in class, then you began studying more often. Rule of thumb: prefer "since" when your intent is to convey "from the time that".

3. "as" is somewhat acceptable, but in your particular statement structure "as" has more useful meanings of "abstractly analogous" or "synchronously". Example: "I like apples as you like oranges" conveys that my liking is similar to your liking, i.e. equivalently strong/weak/notable/etc. Example: "I make dinner as you set the table" conveys that we do these tasks at the same time in the same place. Rule of thumb: prefer "as" when your intent is to convey "sameness".

4. "for" can be acceptable, although I would never expect to hear it in normal conversation. It would come across as overly-academic, or possibly epic or religious. Example: "We eat well tonight, for tomorrow we go to war." Rule of thumb: prefer "for" when you want to be poetic and inspirational.

Dictionary.com has a definition for clunk as follows:

4. Informal. a stupid person; clunkhead.

However, as FumbleFingers remarks in a comment to the question, it is a rare epithet. Searching for "we were clunks", the mighty engine can tell me in 0.17 seconds that the result is unique in cyberspace. Out of the 46 results given for "we were both clunks", 44 of them are direct quotations of that book, and the first and second results link to this question.