In the following sentence: "They are ……. wasting their time." Would "simply", "merely" and "only" be interchangeable? When I was a student of English I was taught the use of "simply" in formal writing should be restricted to its use as an adverb of "simple". That was long ago and I wonder whether this is still valid in 2014.
EDIT (2019) By formal writing I mean any e-mail or letter where you wish to sound educated, impersonal, and following the rules of etiquette. You would avoid the use of slang words, colloquialisms, or whatever constructions that would make a grammarian cringe.
Best Answer
I checked more than a dozen English usage and style guides from the past 100 years and found two treatments of simply that seriously discuss the merits of restricting its use. From Eric Partridge, Usage and Abusage, revised edition (1957):
From Bergen Evans & Cornelia Evans, A Dictionary of Contemporary English (1957):
After 1957, however, I don't find any mention of simply except glancingly by Barbara Wallraff in Word Court (2000), where a New York Times reader argues that it is a superfluous emphasis word in the phrase "simply and more clearly." But in addressing it as part of a wall of complaining sound from readers about modifiers that may or may not be superfluous, Wallraff quickly loses track of it in the mass of examples. At least I think she does. An alternative theory is that she slyly dismisses such criticism by using simply in the disapproved way in the final sentence of her comment:
The overwhelming majority of style and usage guides since 1957 don't address the question of simply at all. From this profound silence, I infer that at some point after 1957—perhaps in 1958—idiomatic usage of simply in the sense of "only" or "merely" became so commonplace that people in the style and usage game stopped worrying about whether using it in that way would doom listeners and readers to needless struggles with ambiguity.
The concerns that Partridge and Evans & Evans expressed about simply do not seem to trouble their present-day counterparts. Today, you can use simply to mean "in a simple way" or you can use it to mean "merely" or you can use it to mean "absolutely"—and in each instance, practically no one will flinch at the informality of the usage, and almost everyone will follow your meaning unerringly.