I've come across the phrase "History teaches, never trust a Cecil!" in different places (among others, in the Netflix series "The Crown" with regards to Lord Salisbury).
While the sentiment is easy to appreciate, given the illustrious history of the Cecils as courtiers, I feel that the shared form points to a literary origin of sorts. I just haven't been able to find it.
Could anybody please help?
Best Answer
I have only a rather obvious and unsatisfying bit of research to offer, but as no one has previously cited a contemporaneous news item regarding the expression "Never trust a Cecil" as it was used in 1998 in connection with Lord Cranborne, here is the earliest one that a Google search finds. From "Hague's history lesson," in The Economist (December 3, 1998):
A straightforward reading of the opening quip suggests that the speaker wasn't invoking an old aphorism about the untrustworthiness of the Cecils, but drawing a playful (albeit unflattering) extemporaneous connection between the present Lord Cranborne and his slithery ancestors.
Better research than mine may turn up a much older expression along the lines of "A Cecil's word is as good as the Devil's." Until that happens, however, I'm inclined to see the expression as a witty modern-day invention—and very likely the senior Liberal Democrat's one (regrettably anonymous) claim to 15 minutes of fame.
Update (July 5, 2019)
At least one author since 1998 suggests that the truism about the slyness of the Cecils has been around for a while. From Elizabeth Bowen, "Note on Eire": Espionage Reports Winston Churchill, 1040–1942 (1999) [snippet view]:
Still, for a "piece of English wisdom," the warning "Never trust a Cecil" doesn't leave much of a paper trail through the years. Bowen's note would be far more compelling if it had appeared before—rather than a year after—the incident reported in The Economist, althought it's intriguing in any case.
An interesting (and much earlier) remark in Phil Harum, "Pencil Points," in the [Parkes, New South Wales] Western Champion (March 16, 1922) makes the opposite recommendation—"trust a Cecil"—albeit in a rather backhanded way:
The notion that "a Cecil" has a certain affinity for the public sphere also appears in "Imperial Parliament: Notes on Careers," in the [Newcastle, New South Wales] Northern Times (November 3, 1916):
A couple of references to the underhandedness—or political astuteness—of "a Cecil" appear in seventeenth-century sources. From William Lloyd, "A Sermon Preached Before the House of Lords, on November 5, 1680" (1680):
And from An Account of the Late Horrid Conspiracy to Depose Their Present Majesties, K. William and Q. Mary, to Bring in the French and the Late King James, and Ruine the City of London (1691):
The expression "a Cecil's plot" may refer to the charge sometimes made that Robert Cecil, the chief discoverer of the 1605 Gunpowder Plot, invented the whole thing. A footnote in John Gerard, What Was the Gunpowder Plot? (1897) gives a snapshot of Robert Cecil's reputation:
In the main text on that same page, Gerard offers the following remarks:
Conclusions
Prominant Cecils have demonstrated their mastery of political intrigue since the days of Lord Burghley, so it is plausible that there might be (as Elizabeth Bowen, writing in 1999, asserts there is) a "piece of English wisdom that warns, 'Never trust a Cecil'." Nevertheless, I have been unable to find any published instance of that piece of wisdom, expressed in approximately those terms, prior to the 1998 Economist article reporting a senior Liberal Democrat's use of it.
More-general warnings about not trusting proud, ambitious, or selfish men do appear in the last third of the seventeenth century. For example, from Richard Baxter, A Christian Directory, or, A Summ of Practical Theologie and Cases of Conscience Directing Christians How to Use Their Knowledge and Faith, How to Improve All Helps and Means, and to Perform All Duties, How to Overcome Temptations, and to Escape or Mortifie Every Sin (1673):
And Baxter again, speaking more generally this time, in A Treatise of Self-Denial (1675):
So Baxter would undoubtedly endorse the proposition "Never trust a Cecil or any other ambitious or proud or selfish person, or anyone whose interests differ even a whit from your own." That pretty well covers it.