I hope this question is not too basic.
I recently edited a question and was accused of correcting a phrase that was grammatically correct to a phrase that is now wrong.
The context is:
I have Sodium and Potassium.
This type of element (i.e. elements considered to be metals)…
I changed the second sentence to
This type of elements…
because I thought there are two elements in this context.
Which of the above usage is correct? And Why?
Thanks in advance!
EDIT:
To make my question more obvious, I've made up some more complete examples:
He prepared some French fries and insomnia cookies, assuming that this type of (crispy) snacks would fit my appetite.
I am recently addicted to Triumph of Death and Tessellation; when I listen to this type of (metal) songs, I feel alive.
Is there a trusted source which claims the use of "this type of things" to be ungrammatical?
UPDATE:
Thank you all for your input. But I am more confused now.
While most of the comments seem to agree upon the same rule, some of the answers have different opinions on this. (hence downvoted?)
Could this be a preference then, where the majority of native speakers prefer not to use "this type of things"?
Best Answer
The original version of the sentence was correct:
Sodium and potassium are a single "type of element" (considered to be metal), despite being more than one element, so "element" should be singular.
Even if your list was many longer, it would still be a single "type of element":
If, instead you had:
This is when you get to pluralize, and you would make both parts plural.
The two "types" here are "metals" and "noble gasses".
The same is true with your other examples:
In this example, there's still only one type of snack... crispy, so this should be written:
And:
There's only one type of song... metal.
Now, to add to this, it's not uncommon in actual use to find examples with mixed singular and plural forms like your example. Right now, I'd say they're ungrammatical but whether they remain ungrammatical could be considered to be in flux.
For the time being, if you make sure to ask yourself, "How many types are there?", you should be able to be sure to use the correct form.
This earlier question addresses your issue as well:
And here's another one that might help: