Learn English – Two quite different meanings of “bear”

etymologyhomographs

As a noun, a bear is a type of carnivore. As a verb, to bear means to support or produce.

I wonder how the two meanings finally ended up in one single word. Is there any connection between the two meanings which I don’t know yet?

Best Answer

TLDR: Probably not, but maybe. Both words seem to derive from two different PIE roots that we’ve reconstructed to the same spelling (*bher), so it is no surprise therefore that they should continue to be spelled the same way. See etymonline for more.


  • For the ursid, Old English used bera, cognate to Old (and modern) Norse björn, and which both drew from older roots relating to the color brown, one of the creature’s most common colors.

  • For the verb you’re referring to, Old English used the strong verb beran. It had the same senses as the Modern English verb bear.

Those two are already so close that there is every reason for the two of them to wind up being spelled the same way in Modern English, where it remains a strong verb: bear, bore, borne.

And that is probably the end of the story.

However, there might be one other trace. We already know that a conjectured Proto-Indo-European root *bʰer‑ for the verb must also be behind the cognate Latin verb fero (from infinitive ferre). So the Latin verb fero and Old English verb beran do share a common ancestor. The Latin verb meant several things, but amongst these were the senses of its Old English cognate.

There is some speculation, however, that there is also a connection between the Old English noun bera and the Latin adjective ferus meaning “wild”, now spelled fiero in Italian and Spanish. The OED cites an author Fick as equating these, in that the bear was the wild beast (the bestia fiera) of the north.

However, such a connection between bera and fera is questionable and remains to be demonstrated. That’s because the proposed PIE root for ferus “wild” is now *ǵʰwēr‑ instead, not *bʰer‑ as before with the verb. It is possible that the wild aspect reinforced the brown one, but I for one am not convinced, as I do not believe that Latin ferus for wild and Latin fero for “I bear” have been shown to be related.

Related Topic