According to @Mahnax's answer to this question, the Chicago Manual of Style Online states that the correct sequence of footnote symbols is as follows:
* (asterisk; but do not use if p values occur in the table; see 3.78)
† (dagger)
‡ (double dagger)
§ (section mark)
|| (parallels)
# (number sign, or pound)
What were the actual reasons that gave rise to this sequence? Could it be traceable back to the typewriters of 50 or 100 years ago having keys in that order?
Best Answer
This Wikipedia article on the dagger (archived by Swarthmore College Computer Society) claims:
Robert Bringhurst's 2005 The Elements of Typographic Style (version 3.1) (nicknamed Bringhurst's Bible by typographers) says the traditional order of symbols is *, †, ‡, §, ‖, ¶ and goes on to say:
The order doesn't come from typewriters, which were invented in 1868, because they were used as footnotes before this. Here's an example from a 1792 magazine:
And the asterisk, dagger, double-dagger, section mark:
But they also used numbered footnotes, especially when there were many footnotes, such as these nine:
Here's Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine from 1819 with six footnotes; asterisk, dagger, double-dagger, section mark, parallels and pilcrow:
The asterisk is used before a dagger to denote birth and death dates. Typographers Hoefler & Frere-Jones say:
The Sweet Sound of Punctuation by Yves Peters says of the dagger:
It also says another name for dagger is obelisk. So: asterisk and obelisk => Asterix and Obelix!