Word Choice – ‘What Memory!’ or ‘What a Memory!’?

word-choice

Even though the second one seems right, is the first one totally wrong? It sounds ok to me. Correct me if I am wrong. Please explain if possible. Thanks. 🙂

Context:

Someone recollects a proverb that he/she read somewhere. I am intending to praise this person. So which usage would be apt for the situation?

Best Answer

Neither is wrong. They just mean different things.

“What memory!” refers to "memory" as a general concept.

If someone remembered things very well, you might say "What memory!" to mean "What (good) memory (you have)!"

“What a memory!” refers to a specific memory.

If someone told you a story, you might say "What a memory!" to mean "What a (good) memory (you have just talked about)!"

Edit: As noted in the comments, you could say "What a memory!" to refer to the general concept of memory as well. The example would be similar to "What a (good) memory (you have)!"

Related Topic