Learn English – What’s the difference between un- adjectives and -less adjectives

synonyms

What's the difference, if any, between

  • talentless and untalented
  • luckless and unlucky
  • dauntless and undaunted
  • hapless and unhappy, etc.?

Can the answer to this be generalized, i.e. is it always the same kind or shade of difference, or does the difference differ in each individual pair?

Best Answer

According to Michael Quinion, Ologies and Isms: Word Beginnings and Endings (2002), -less words fall into two main categories: words where the -less form indicates simply "without" (as, for example, bottomless, childless, defenceless, and lawless), and words where the -less form "indicate[s] something that is unaffected by the action of the verb, or some failure or inability to carry out that action" (as, for example, dauntless, quenchless, relentless, tireless).

In contrast, Quinion says, the prefix un- usually lends the simple meaning "not" to the resulting word; but in some instances it "often has a stronger and less neutral force than just negation (so it is not equivalent to NON-): unkind can mean active cruelty rather than simple lack of kindness; to say someone is un-American can imply an active antagonism to American ways. Furthermore, with verbs, Quinion says, un- "usually has the sense of reversing some state" (as, for example, unburden, unlock, unsettle, untie).

So on a basic level, the split between -less words and un- words is the difference between "without" and "not." But in addition, Quinion suggests, some -less words imply a resistance to an embedded verb, and some un- words either express a reversal of an embedded verb or go beyond mere negation to suggest an active opposition to an embedded adjective.