If I want to form the plural of “Valentine’s” as a short form of “Saint Valentine’s Day” – where do I put the apostrophe(s)? Is it possible at all?
I believe that Valentines’, although the normal plural form of a genitive ending in “s”, would be wrong here since that would mean “the day of the people who are called Valentine”. So what’s right? Valentine’s’ ?
Here’s an example of where I’d use this form:
She had spent so many Valentine’s’ alone that she now loathed the very mention of this day.
– Of course I could simply write it out … but where’s the fun in that?
Best Answer
In my experience, “Valentine’s” is less common than “Valentine’s Day” — usually only the “St.” is dropped1 — so I think the usual phrasing would be:
Another option, if you really want to use “Valentine’s” alone (without “Day”), is to treat it as a proper noun, and write:
(Compare “She had spent Christmas alone so many times […]”.)