Is there a good adjective to describe someone who knows they're above others, and while not boastful, they are not forthcoming or approachable? I'm not trying to describe someone who is antisocial or outright unkind.
For example, think of a popular girl in high-school who knows she gets a lot of attention. She holds this fact above everyone else and thus only stays to her social group of similar girls, mostly ignoring everyone else.
I could never muster the courage to approach the ___ girl who sat in
front of me in Biology class.
This word probably has a negative connotation, but not synonymous with malicious or reclusive.
Best Answer
Based solely on your description, my first thought was haughty or one of its synonyms:
Another that I like, which is less pejorative, is lofty:
However, in the context of your sample sentence, there is one clearly appropriate word:
Cool is a word with a lot of nuances of meaning, many of which work in your context:
At least in the US, a student who is attractive and popular and slightly "above" the regular student body, but without being actively boastful or cruel, is almost the definition of "cool".