Etymoline hyphenates rock-bottom and provides a rather vague origin as a synonym of bedrock:
"lowest possible," 1884, from the noun phrase meaning "bedrock" (1815), also figurative, from rock (n.1) + bottom (n.).
What I would like to know is how this phrase came to be. Every time I hear it, I always imagine a diver that "hits" the bottom of the sea, and so from there he can only go up, not down. But looking around the internet, I see that it has nothing to do with diving. Some say it was first used in agriculture, others in mining.
Is there any source that clearly states how this phrase came to be?
PS: Apparently, this is an American expression. Has it made its way across the ocean?
Best Answer
Christine Ammer, The American Heritage Dictionary of Idioms, second edition (2013) has this entry for rock bottom:
Presumably, the digging that Ammer has in mind is digging through dirt. I remember as a child watching my grandfather use a two-handled post-hole digger to excavate holes for a new fence line on his farm. When the implement hit the limestone substrate, that was the end of the digging because he had reached rock bottom.
Use of 'rock bottom' in a literal sense
Instances of "rock bottom" in the literal sense of bedrock are quite common in nineteenth-century U.S. publications. For example, an article by John Hale on salt resources in West Virginia, excerpted in George Atkinson, History of Kanawha County: From Its Organization in 1789 Until the Present (1876):
As this instance indicates, "rock bottom" doesn't refer simply to rocky material but rather to solid bedrock.
Early use of 'rock bottom' in a figurative sense
Although Ammer dates idiomatic use of "rock bottom" to the late 1800s, I have found instances from 1865 onward. Some early instances involve the idea of a firm foundation rather than an economic nadir. For example, from "The Pacific Railroad," in the New York Tribune (October 20, 1865):
Others, however, use the term in the sense of (as Ammer puts it) "absolute bottom"—the sense in which most people use the idiom today. From "Our Letter from Washington, D.C.," in the [San Francisco] Daily Alta California (May 1, 1865):
From "Business Prospects," in the Ashtabula [Ohio] Weekly Telegraph (November 24, 1866), reprinted from the New York Tribune (again):
And from "Resumption—Two Ways," in the [Philadelphia, Pennsylvania] Evening Telegraph (November 29, 1867):
Early idiomatic use of 'rock bottom' as a compound modifier
References to "rock bottom prices" also appear as early as 1865. From a rather mystifying advertisement in the Cambridge [Massachusetts] Chronicle (March 25, 1865):
And from an item in the the Rural New Yorker, reprinted in the [Albany New York] Cultivator & Country Gentleman (October 13, 1870):
By 1891 "rock-bottom prices" was a recognized American idiom. From James Dixon, Dictionary of Idiomatic Phrases (1891):
In a prefatory note titled "Explanation of Signs," Dixon reports that the designation "Familiar" means "The phrase is used in familiar conversation, but is not admissible in polite society."
Early idiomatic use of 'reached rock bottom' and 'hit rock bottom'
An instance of "reached rock bottom" appears in L.U. Reavis, St. Louis, The Commercial Metropolis of the Mississippi Valley (1874):
And another appears in an advertisement for Rivet & Partridge Dry Goods, in the Indianapolis [Indiana] News (November 3, 1877):
The earliest match I've been able to find for the exact phrase "hit rock bottom" is from C.A. Jenkens, The Story of Pot Hooks: Or, Society as Seen by a Backwoods Philosopher (1892):
This instance is striking because the speaker is using "rock bottom" in a positive sense, although the author may be having the speaker misuse the idiom for humorous effect.
More typical is the following instance from a headline in the Wichita [Kansas] Daily Eagle (July 22, 1894):
That's a farmer's life for you: you finally get a year with really good weather, and prices for your crop fall to rock bottom.
Early non-economic idiomatic use of 'rock bottom'
As for early non-economic figurative use of "rock bottom," here is an instance from "400 Oddfellows and Wives Attend," in the Hammond [Indiana] Times (April 30, 1912):