Which of the following sentences is correct: Can you not travel during this period? or Are you unable to travel during this period?

british-englishgrammarmodal-verbs

I came across the following sentence written by a supposedly native (British) English speaker in a text I'm currently editing and it immediately struck me as being odd:

  • We offer special discounts to people traveling with their pets during the holiday season. Can you not travel with your pet during this period?

Is "Can you not" used correctly in this sentence, knowing that the writer was supposed to convey the meaning that someone cannot travel/is unable to travel during the period concerned?

Unless I'm mistaken, "can you not" normally conveys the meaning of a request to do something or rather not do something, i.e. "please do not travel during this period". Wouldn't it be more accurate to say "Are you unable to travel during this period?" Is"can you not" as it is used here an instance of dialectal or regional variation (e.g. typical British usage) I am not aware of?

Best Answer

"can you not," is a British English, albeit somewhat archaic dialectal pattern. Ashworth is correct that the spelling “traveling” implies the advertisement is not British (“travelling” would be). In America, the word honor, versus British honour. The change in spelling, only occurs if the speaker/writer catches themselves, or another points it out.

The phrase is used like this: Can you not call her? With the emphasis on the word not. The sentences do look strange placed side by side. The first is an advertisement (business). Followed by the second sentence, asking a personal and challenging question (inappropriate usage for business). It is a 2021 advertisement attempting to be personal.

Related Topic