I am in a bit of a predicament to say the least. I am currently in my second playthrough and, before starting NG+, I had the bright idea of murdering every single NPC in the game. Needless to say, the game gods were not pleased and I was labeled a "sinner". Regardless I thought to myself: "whatever, I will be fine once I start my next playthrough… I'm sure my slate will be clean."
Oh how wrong I was…
Now, I am getting invaded every 5 minutes by an arbiter out for revenge. But that's not even the worse part…
After finally making it to
Brightstone Cove Tseldora (Chapel Threshold)
I met with my good pal
Cromwell the Pardoner (we go way back)
However, whenever I try "Ask for pardon", he tells me you have not sinned, which is simply wrong… Not to mention, my Player Info section clearly labels me as a sinner.
Does anyone know of a way to pardon my sins?
Best Answer
According to the wikipedia page for Cromwell The Pardoner
so maybe now that you are in NG+ you have already lost NPC hostility and that's why he cannot do much for you.
However, according to a reddit's user who did quite a lot of testing there's a way for you to remove your sinner status: