The quote you replied to had an individual who was playing one game
locally, signed onto a new device with gamecenter, and basically
attached the brand new game to his gamecenter.
So you are left with an old iPhone with your locally played "Good"
game, and a new iPhone with a brand new village attached to
gamecenter?
You can only have one village attached to gamecenter at a time. If the
above is right, then you have 2 options. Create a new gamecenter
account and attach it to the good game, or if you want to keep the
game on your old gamecenter, there will be extra steps. Either way,
you still need to have network capabilities on the old iPhone.
To re-use the old gamecenter currently attached to the new game:
Create brand new gamecenter account Close CoC and log out of
gamecenter on the new iPhone. Log into the new iPHone with the brand
new gamecenter you just created. Launch CoC, when prompted to save
that village to this new GC, accept. Close CoC, launch it from within
the gamecenter app itself, play it for a few minutes, then...
This will have severed the old gamecenter to new village connection.
Go back on the old iPhone and make sure you are logged in with that
old gamecenter and launch CoC (good village). This should prompt you
to attach that village to the old gamecenter. Same thing, close,
launch through gamecenter, play it a few minutes, etc. Close CoC
Next step would be to make sure CoC is closed (force quit it) and you
log out of that new gamecenter on the new iPhone. Then log in with the
old gamecenter and launch CoC, which will bring the good game over to
the new device.
I know when I attached my second iOS device to my gamecenter and launched CoC, it asked me if I wanted to link the village attached to the gamecenter account to this phone. It will start to walk you through the tutorial, but just go through it until you are on your own, login to gamecenter and then accept the popup from CoC.
Best Answer
Simply do the following:
EDIT: See this for more info:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/562925-How-do-I-overwrite-my-account