After first beating Malthael in Diablo 3: Reaper of Souls, I received 3 legendary drops.
- Reaper's Wraps
- Reaper's Fear
- A legendary pair of boots that dropped probably because I was lucky.
After reading some on the wiki page for the Reapers' items, it seems that they only drop upon killing Malthael.
Are there other legendaries that are only dropped by defeating Malthael?
If so, what are the other legendaries that are only dropped by Malthael?
Best Answer
Malthael's "reserved" legendaries are Reaper's Wraps (Plan) and Reaper's Fear (crafting material). The Plan is a guaranteed drop the first time you kill Malthael, you got lucky to get the Reaper's Fear with it. I killed him twice with no such luck. The pair of boots is part of the First-kill-reward as well. I got a helm and the Plan