fallout-4
I was working in my settlements and found my first Brahmin in Starlight Drive In. After some research on the internet, I found a way to keep it in one spot using the feeding bathtub, but still, WHY do I keep it? Nobody on the internet seems to have the real answer. Does it add food? Does it makes people happy?
Basically, what is the use of Brahmins in my settlements?
They'll destroy as many structures within the settlement and kill as many people as possible. You'll have the opportunity to repair anything that is broken in Workshop mode:
Obviously if settlers die, that's final.
For a duration of time, the happiness level of the settlement will also be impacted. This is especially the case if sufficient damage has been caused to the structures of the settlement to cause a shortage in any resources (power, water, food).
You don't have to look after that beyond the first few missions for the Minutemen (you don't even have to do these, if you don't want to). The first few missions for Preston and Sturges will have you setting up power, water and food in Sanctuary and from there onwards settlements can be largely ignored and depending on how you play the game. There are spoilers below. I'm not marking them up and you have been warned.
You'll get Sanctuary early on and meet up with Preston at Concord and this will fully establish a settlement with people in it. This settlement is the primary base of the Minutemen and will remain as such unless you progress the Minutemen quest line and retake the Castle, at which point this becomes the primary Minutemen settlement but the original survivors will remain in Sanctuary.
In addition to these two settlements, if you continue with the Minutemen you will frequently find yourself in a position where Preston wants to expand by helping another settlement, which will then join your cause and potentially get attacked, prompting you for assistance (which you can ignore if you don't mind them dying or if that settlement is properly secured).
If you do not progress the Minutemen quest line and instead go with the Institute, you won't end up getting any additional settlements throughout the game.
If you follow the Railroad, they'll ask you to take a settlement as their new safehouse after one of their existing safehouses is destroyed by the Institute. This settlement doesn't need a broadcast tower as part of the mission and therefore won't generate a population of settlers that need looking after.
If you follow the Brotherhood of Steel, the airport ends up becoming one of your settlements during their quest line.
The additional settlement (or in the instance of the Minutemen, a settlement of your choosing) is required in order to build the Signal Interceptor which is used to infiltrate the Institute later in the game.
Best Answer
According to this post on the Steam Community forums brahmin increase the productivity of the settlement.