I am stuck on the Companions questline. In my journal, "Proving Honor" is marked as completed, but the top objective "Return to Jorrvaskr" isn't filled in, so it may be bugged. The Silver Hand quest has not been started.
When I talk to any of the leaders, they say "Didn't Skjor already give you a job?" or something.
I went through all the misc objectives that had to do with killing bandit leaders and none of them were related to Skjor (I finished them and the bounty collection was always someone else).
Could this have anything to do with another questline (e.g. civil war) not being complete?
Best Answer
I have had this also. I think it's a glitch rather than a bug. For me, it was that I hadn't completed one of the radient quests, namely Animal Extermination. I thought that I'd picked that one up at a random innkeeper, not the Companions. Once I completed that quest, the questline went on as usual.
The problem for me was to try to filter out what specific task I'd been given since quest descriptions sometimes aren't completely clear as to who gave it to you.