How to get seasoned flaky meat

red-dead-redemption-2

I am on challenge 10 of herbalist and I need the flakey meat.
Went on catching a northern pike which gives this meat.

The problem is that I can’t get the meat seasoned. When I keep the fish and choose to cook immediately it does not ask me to season or shows in the menu either.

The only thing I can do is stow it on the horse or cook which gives me plain flakey fish.

Am I missing something or am I catching the wrong fish?

Best Answer

Press left or right on the D-pad to switch between the recipes. The seasoned versions aren’t shown in the list of crafting options unless you are already at capacity for the plain version of the meat.