The Clicker item seems to change the character to look/behave like another, but does this mean that all the achievments are going to account for the new character?
The Binding of Isaac Rebirth – Can Achievements Be Earned for the Original Character Using the ‘Clicker’ Item?
the-binding-of-isaac-afterbirththe-binding-of-isaac-rebirth
Related Solutions
The item you have not unlocked will be replaced by a random item that you have unlocked. (Your option 1.)
If you mean the second screenshot, your "mask" is due to the Gnawed Leaf, as you can see this is the appearence:
That's the fifth item in your first screenshot.
This item is a reference to the "Tanuki suit" from Super Mario Bros 3, which also has a similar tail and the ability to turn into a statue.
Related Topic
- What does count as taking damage
- What happens when I pick up the Black Candle when I have Curse of the Labyrinth
- Is BFFS! item affecting Lilith’s damage
- The Binding of Isaac Afterbirth – What is the Second Bearded Form of the Keeper Character About?
- Binding of Isaac – How Does Apollyon’s Starting Item ‘Void’ Work?
- The Binding of Isaac – How Does Mom’s Box Work with Swallowed Trinkets?
- Cheat to unlock the Binding of Isaac’s achievements
Best Answer
As with all items that change which character you're playing as (for example, Judas' Shadow, Lazarus' Rags, or the Ankh which turns you into ??? (Blue Baby)), finishing a run with that "new" character will unlock achievements for the "new" character only. The clicker changes which character you're playing as in the same way, so you will only unlock achievements tied to whatever character you are using at the time the achievement unlocks.