I go into the nether on a multiplayer server with my friend, and we do some exploring.
The next day, I go through, turn around, and see an obsidian portal that just hasn't been lit yet. We light it, and it takes us back to our place.
My friend swears he didn't place it there, and I can't imagine he did. It definitely wasn't someone else, as this is an FFA server and had they seen our portal our house would be in flames.
Plot twist, minutes later a couple of pigmen come through our portal and into our house.
What the hell? Did they build this portal?
Best Answer
No. Assuming a relatively vanilla server, and that your friend is being truthful; pigmen are not capable of building. Given the following info from the Minecraft Wiki entry on nether portals:
The more likely scenario is that a ghast was firing at either yourself or your friend, and one of the fireballs managed to 'turn off' the portal. Whomever was inside the nether at the time died, and thus returned to the overworld by respawning. The next time either of you enter your portal it checks for an active portal, finds none, and creates a new active portal near the old one.