Minecraft – /tp Relative Coordinates

As most minecraft command makers know, entering ~ instead of a coordinate number results in the relative position of the executing entity. Apparently, the /tp command has a special property with relative coordinates.

I am trying to make a command that teleports all other entities to the same position as the player, but on a absolute Z value. This will make a third person, 2D-looking effect. Here's my command:

execute @p ~ ~ ~ /tp @e[type=!Player,r=20] ~ ~ -645

This does not work. In the /tp command, it appears that the ~s are no longer relative to the executing entity, but the entity being teleported.

A similar command works like I expect it to. It places a block at the player's position, but again at a fixed z position:

execute @p ~ ~ ~ /setblock ~ ~ -650 minecraft:stone

I am wondering how to make the ~s in the /tp command to execute relative to the executing entity, not the entity being teleported.

Both the commands are inside a repeating, non-conditional, redstone-requiring command blocks. They are both powered by levers.

I am on Minecraft 1.12 Mac edition, singleplayer world.

Any help is appreciated! Thanks in advance!