I've read a couple different posts on various forums that say forester camps should not plant trees in the winter, but instead focus on cutting for additional firewood resources.
Is this so the cutting will happen faster (to produce firewood faster)?
I've got a pretty bare spot with not much more than saplings around my forester camp now, as a result of this tactic. Am I missing something?
Best Answer
TLDR: I find micromanaging my foresters outside of an emergency to be entirely unnecessary. If you're having trouble keeping up with logs or firewood, you should reexamine your town's layout, the availability of general laborers, and the condition of your workers.
Long Answer:
As nickson104 says, there is some usual advice to give some forester huts orders to "plant only" to maximize the harvest of the herbalists & gatherers with which they are grouped. In my experience this is an optimization in search of a problem. Once my food industry is in full swing, any drop in production from my gatherers will be more than compensated for by my farmers. And with any reasonable building/firewood demands, production of food and herbs will not noticeably suffer. In addition, with a well rounded diet available, herb consumption can drop to well under a dozen per year for each hundred people.
Now if you do find your town stressed for logs, which is more likely to happen in winter, two solutions present themselves.
Remember, if you're trying to accelerate your Firewood production, these things need to happen near the woodcutter's stockpiles. If they are forced to regularly march to a distant stockpile for logs, this will just slow them down. To optimize firewood production, I'll often put a large (10x5) stockpile directly outside my forest cluster with my woodcutter just across the street from it. While I find the starting log quota of 200 suits me for much of the game, I will often bump the Firewood quota by an extra 1000 when I either start trading in firewood (the buffer for large trades is invaluable) or when I start mining/trading for coal (having the markets carrying far more firewood than coal means that's what the people generally will use as fuel. That coal is for tools gosh-darn-it!)
Lastly, why are we in this predicament in the 1st place?