Bioshock Infinite – Understanding the ‘Only One Obstacle’ Mission

bioshock-infinite

At the Lutece home, you find the following photograph:

Only one obstacle

What is the "only one obstacle?"

This answer guesses that it means the lighthouse supervisor, but that seems pretty unlikely…

Best Answer

Needless to say – SPOILERS AHEAD!

Due to lack of other in-game sources, and seeing that "only one obstacle" was written on a picture of the lighthouse, the "only one obstacle" that the answer you mentioned says (the lighthouse keeper) is the closest possible "obstacle". This is also since the lighthouse keeper maintains and guards the "entrance" to Columbia (the "chair" in the lighthouse). Booker won't be able to go to Columbia unless the Luteces find some way to deal with the lighthouse keeper.

There's a hint in the lighthouse that Comstock ordered the lighthouse keeper to stop Booker from getting to Columbia:
Click on image thumbnail below to view larger, original image.

enter image description here

In the answers to this question: What was up with the coin flip question? - we learned that the "Booker DeWitt" player character is the 123rd Booker DeWitt that attempted the rescue of Elizabeth. All other Bookers that the Luteces assisted in rescuing Elizabeth have failed for some reason. We also learned of constants and variables in the different multiverses. e.g. Booker flipping heads and not "rowing", is a constant, and whether Booker chooses a cage or a bird brooch is a variable.

Why the lighthouse supervisor was the "one last obstacle" will depend whether he is a constant or a variable.

Possible explanation on why the lighthouse keeper is the "only one obstacle" if he's a variable:

[The Lutece twins] tried several scenarios to get Booker to get on that chair of his own volition, and only the one where the lighthouse keeper was killed execution style was the one that worked.

i.e. Booker will only get on the chair if the lighthouse keeper is killed.

Source: Comment at Reddit /r/Games subreddit post, "Lingering mysteries of Bioshock Infinite" by Reddit user, Hector_Kur
If the dead lighthouse keeper is a constant:

Now, in the Lutece labs, you find a picture of the lighthouse with a red circle marked around it and the words "ONLY ONE OBSTACLE" next to it. Their plan was to send Booker through the lighthouse, and the only obstacle was the man guarding it himself.

i.e. In all universes where the Luteces sent Booker to Columbia to rescue Elizabeth, the "only one obstacle" in getting Booker to Columbia is always the lighthouse keeper.

Source: Answer that OP mentioned on the "Who is the dead man in the lighthouse?" question, by @Answergaming