Trying for amethyst but got something different. What is it

Rare dragons are certainly less likely to be bred when they're an option. It's all a matter of chance, though there's been some unproven theories that the dragon you put on the left side of the breeding menu determines the order of elements of the egg. It doesn't seem to hold true.

Generally assume the breed will yield a random possible combination, and note that rare dragons are very rare, I'd say maybe less than a 10% chance. I don't think there's any formal numbers. From experience only Rare dragons have a different breeding chance, everything else, assume an even chance of all other possible results. If there is a difference, it's not large enough to fuss over.

Special Event dragons also tend to be "Rare" at approximately the same rate as the Sun/Moon/Rainbow dragons. Generally you'll want to stop everything and start trying to breed time-limited dragons immediately until you get one, or two if you want a breeding pair.

Note the Epic Breeding Island advertises that you have a higher chance of rares. It doesn't seem extremely significant; rare dragons are still rare on the breeding island. In fact I haven't noticed a perceptible difference, but if you're trying to breed for rares you might as well try the island first.

Also note that breeding two dragons always gives you that same dragon (best I can tell), so breeding two Rare Rainbow dragons has a 100% chance of giving a rainbow dragon.

You are more likely to get higher scores if your element matches rather than opposes the arena's element. I put a plant in fire and got bronze, plant in plant and got gold. I believe that is the only difference.

I looked it up before too because I had a similar question. I did not find much on this actually, so I tested it myself and that outcome was always mis-match = bronze or silver match = silver or gold. (I unfortunately decided to test this after all my dragons were level 7, not 10 yet but all were at least 7 so many came out silver either way).