Say, we refuse to accept Granny Rags' quest where she asks to poison the elixir supply located in the bandit area – Does this imply that Slackjaw will not give out the non-lethal version of the quest for killing the twin brothers?
Since he explicitly says that he only asks for our help because many of his men were poisoned by the elixir, so half of his gang group are now Weepers. So, if we don't touch the elixir by not doing Granny Rags' quest, will we not get non-lethal version of the main quest? i.e. Will he not ask us to get the safe code?
Best Answer
Regardless of your interactions with Granny Rags, Slackjaw will offer you the non-lethal way of dealing with the Twins. His dialog changes somewhat, but otherwise the quest is exactly the same. I ran this both ways - one run through the game I helped Granny Rags, and in the other I avoided her altogether. Both times I non-lethally dealt with the Twins with Slackjaw's help.
If you haven't poisoned Slackjaw's elixir machine, though, you can use it when you return to his hideout later.
If you bypass Granny Rags altogether: