When you create a message using the notebook, I noticed you can get it rated as either "fine" or "foul". I know getting a "fine" rating restores health. What happens though when you get a foul rating? Does it have any negative consequences?
What happens when your message is considered “foul”
bloodborne
Best Answer
As far as I can tell (so far) there's no negative consequences. I'm assuming it's purely just an indicator. Lot's of foul ratings = avoid the message, etc.
It's great when your message gets up-voted and you're in a boss fight: You get all that lovely health back!