This question has been bothering me for some time. I know the lore of the game but just can't put my finger on why Jarl Balgruuf didn't side with them. Ulfric really wants him on their side as a true nord and powerful ally. And Jarl Balgruuf Respects him. Whilst the Imperials just want him for his position of power. So can anyone clear up this confusment for me? cheers
Why doesn’t Jarl Balgruuf side with the StormCloaks
the-elder-scrolls-v-skyrim
Related Topic
- Is it possible to kill Ulfric after joining the Stormcloaks
- Why is Jarl Ulfric abusing General Tullius
- How to kill the Jarl
- How to regain neutrality with Stormcloaks and Imperials
- Still finish the Main Questline after siding with the Stormcloaks before finishing Season Unending
- Cannot deliver message to the Jarl of Whiterun
- During Diplomatic Immunity the Sneak skill stopped being effective
Best Answer
Jarl Balgruuf is a devout worshipper of Talos, who hates the Thalmor and the White-Gold Concordat. However, he is also a pragmatist who believes that ensuring the physical safety of his subjects is his primary duty.
He's Conflicted
The conflict between these two urges causes the Jarl a great deal of consternation, and he spends the first part of the game trying to make up his mind. In response to the question "Whose side are you on?", he says
But in the end he chooses peace and safety.
A planned but unused conversation with Vignar Grey-Mane:
Another conversation with Vignar, after the batte of Whiterun:
He also makes clear his opinion of Ulfric and the consequences of his uprising, when asked "What will it take to end the war?":
So, Balgruuf believes that the Nords need the Empire's help to defend themselves from the Thalmor. An independent Skyrim would lack that protection. Furthermore, an independence won through civil war would leave Skyrim weakened and alone.
Because he sees no better choice.
So, although he detests the current situation, he believes it's better than being invaded and conquered. He simply doesn't believe that killing each other helps the Nords' cause.