[RPG] Bag of Holding and fragile items

dnd-5emagic-items

My party has a bag of holding and I have a fetch quest prepared for them. They have to go run a noble woman's errands and pick up items at the store for her. Some are fragile and they are supposed to be holding them because they are going to wind up in combat and have to make checks to make sure the objects don't break. Well, knowing my party, they will put the items in the bag of holding to work around this issue.

My question is, can fragile items break inside the bag of holding if they are not protected in some way and the bag is jostled thus causing the items to bump into each other?

Best Answer

The rules for Bag of Holding are surprisingly silent on what kind of space is the interior of the bag. Luckily, Handy Haversack has a relevant entry:

Placing the haversack inside an extradimensional space created by a bag of holding, portable hole, or similar item instantly destroys both items and opens a gate to the Astral Plane.

Emphasis mine.

From the earlier Q&A we can see that extradimensional spaces are actually demiplanes - connected, but separate planes of existence. This tells us that fragile items are not in the material realm if they are inside the bag of holding. Thus, we can assume they are safe enough.

Of course DM is allowed to rule that since the bag's fabric exists both in the material plane and in the extradimensional space created by the bag, it can transfer hits to its insides. But we are entering a rabbit hole of houseruling now, so I would advise against it.


But I really want these items to be endangered!

If that's the case, just use the right items. For example, a little box that's exactly 2 rings big but can hold 20. It will be extradimensional space in its own right, unsafe to put inside a Bag of Holding at all! An exotic animal's egg could run out of air in the bag. Get creative! And by all means, let them have some items in the bag! They bought it, it was expensive, they deserve to be able to use it in fun ways.