[RPG] Can a Lich create a new phylactery

dnd-5emonstersundead

It looks like 3.5e prevented the creation of a new phylactery.

It looks like some people were saying that it was possible in 4e. (as per comment in link above.)

I'm interested to know whether we have any knowledge of such happening in 5e yet?

Best Answer

Not while their original one exists and it's doubtful if they could after it is destroyed

There is no 5e Lore or rules covering this question specifically, but there are a number of inferences we can make from what we do have.

Can the Lich create multiple simultaneous phylacteries?

(Monster Manual > Lich > Secrets of Undeath)

A lich is created by an arcane ritual that traps the wizard’s soul within a phylactery. Doing so binds the soul to the mortal world, preventing it from traveling to the Outer Planes after death.

This makes it clear that part and parcel of becoming a Lich is binding their soul into their phylactery.

Since their soul is trapped in their original phylactery it is not possible to trap it in a second phylactery simultaneously.

If adventurers were to destroy the phylactery could the Lich create a replacement?

(Monster Manual > Lich > Secrets of Undeath)

A phylactery is traditionally an amulet in the shape of a small box, but it can take the form of any item possessing an interior space into which arcane sigils of naming, binding, immortality, and dark magic are scribed in silver.

They certainly possess the knowledge to create a new item that could become a phylactery.

Can they re-trap their soul in the new item to make it their phylactery?

This is unclear, but they certainly can't use the original "Become a Lich" ritual!

(Monster Manual > Lich > Secrets of Undeath)

With its phylactery prepared, the future lich drinks a potion of transformation [...]. The wizard falls dead, then rises as a lich as its soul is drawn into the phylactery, where it forever remains.

Part of the ritual of trapping their soul in the phylactery is drinking the potion of transformation to turn them into an undead creature.

They can't undergo this transformation twice, thus they would need to find some other way of trapping their soul in the vessel beyond the method in the ritual they used to become a Lich.

Is the soul even available after the phylactery is destroyed for such a modification?

It's not clear.

(Monster Manual > Lich > Secrets of Undeath)

Doing so binds the soul to the mortal world, preventing it from traveling to the Outer Planes after death.

It's also clear from the text that the only thing preventing their soul from travelling to the Outer Planes is their phylactery.

If we presuppose that they could transfer their soul into the new vessel, there is the issue of where the soul is located. There are two possibilities:

  1. When the original is destroyed, the soul goes to the Outer Planes and is thus unavailable for the ritual unless the Lich Plane Shifts and embarks on a quest to find their soul
  2. The soul returns to the undead Lich's current form and is available

In the first case, the Lich has a relatively short amount of time to find the soul before they would decay into a demilich (since they have no phylactery to feed souls into).

(Monster Manual > Demilich)

The immortality granted to a lich lasts only as long as it feeds mortal souls to its phylactery. If it falters or fails in that task, its bones turn to dust until only its skull remains. This “demilich” contains only a fragment of the lich’s malevolent life force — just enough so that if it is disturbed, these remains rise into the air and assume a wraithlike form.

If they either find their soul on the Outer Planes, or the second case applies, the Lich has the same time pressure to discover a method of forcing their soul back into the new vessel before they become a demilich. This is not expected to be an easy task.

Conclusion

The Lich cannot have multiple phylacteries active simultaneously. They can't use the original ritual to create a new phylactery after their first is destroyed, so must find a different ritual (if it is even possible to do). If it is possible finding this ritual will be difficult (and potentially need to be performed on a clock). Even if they have the ritual available, it is unclear if their soul is available to them for the ritual.


Potential exception to the above

If the Lich could be returned to a living being they would then have the time and knowledge to perform the "Become a Lich" ritual again, complete with a new phylactery. There is of course the question of whether or not the ritual works on the same soul twice... if it doesn't then this transformation back to life simply prevents them from becoming a demilich.

If the Lich is less than 200 years old when their phylactery is destroyed they could have someone perform the True Resurrection spell on them to return them to life.

If they are more than 200 years old, then they cannot be returned to life short of Wish or Divine Intervention.