[RPG] Can a non-spellcaster attune to & use a wand or staff that doesn’t require a spellcaster

attunementdnd-5emagic-items

I've been going through the DMG's magic item list, and I notice some wands & staves require attunement without specifying "by a spellcaster". An example is the Wand of Magic Missiles.

Is it the designers' intent that a non-spellcaster be able to fire magic missiles with that wand? Or should this be treated as errata?

Best Answer

Is it the designers' intent that a non-spellcaster be able to fire magic missiles with that wand? Or should this be treated as errata?

This absolutely looks like designers' intent.

The Wands have a variety of restrictions on attunement and they seem to be connected to the rarity / power of the wand.

  • Uncommon: Magic Detection, Magic Missiles, Secrets, Web^
  • Rare: Binding^^, Enemy Detection^, Fear^, Fireballs^^, Lightning Bolts^^, Paralysis^^, Wonder^^
  • Very Rare: Polymorph^^

^ attunement

^^ attunement by spellcaster

More powerful spell wands have a more restrictive attunement requirement. This seems intentional. If you look at the various magical Staves many of them have even more specific requirements than the wands. Like the Staff of Healing requiring attunement by a Bard, Cleric or Druid.

From the rules on creating your own magic item, here is the excerpt on Attunement (DMG 285).

Use these rules of thumb to help you decide:

  • If having all the character in a party pass an item around to gain its lasting benefits would be disruptive, the item should require attunement.
  • If the item grants a bonus that other items also grant, it's a good idea to require attunement so that characters don't try to collect too many of those items.

That last point is really important here.

Do I care if the Rogue has 5 Wands of Detect Magic? Probably not. It's not a really powerful spell. Do I care if the Wizard is walking around with 5 Wands of Fireball? Absolutely! What about the Barbaian? Even more so!

The restrictions not only seem intentional, they seem rational and balanced. Especially given how many classes get access to some magic at some point. I think everyone but the Barbarian has some magic using archetype.