[RPG] Can a spell always counterspell itself

counterspellingmagicpathfinder-1e

The counterspell rules in Pathfinder say some spells can be used to counter other spells (like, say, Darkness can counterspell light spells). But does this override the regular counterspelling rule? In short, can Darkness still counterspell Darkness?

(Note: I'm on smartphone, the ask page doesn't tell me if this question is already asked)

Best Answer

A spell can be used to counterspell a spell of the same name plus any additional spells the spell lists

Counterspells says, "It is possible to cast any spell as a counterspell," then, later, continues, saying, "Some spells can counter other specific spells, often those with diametrically opposed effects" (emphasis mine). These other spells that can be countered by a specific spell are in addition to the spell being able to counterspell itself. (Also see this question.)