The Feywild and Shadowfell are planes parallel to the Prime material plane. Though they are usually depicted as good and evil planes respectively, is there evil that resides in the Feywild, or good that resides in the Shadowfell?
[RPG] Can evil beings be found in the Feywild, and good ones in the Shadowfell
alignmentdnd-4ednd-5eplanes
Related Solutions
You are right. This is an oversight.
8 hours is not long enough to travel to a bordering plane through the deep ethereal, not to mention the journey to get there from the border ethereal.
Even if you could reach the other plane, you would be sent back to the plane you started on as soon as the spell ended. You would have to cast etherealness again to tether you to the new plane and then return to that plane after the first spell ended.
As such, the etherealness spell is not an effective means of planar travel, like the section in the Player's Handbook suggests.
Why the rules then?
Perhaps it is easier to attune a forked, metal rod to the Ethereal Plane for the purposes of plane shift since you can get there via etherealness. Then you can travel to the Ethereal Plane long enough to make it to the inner planes.
Plane Shift
[...]
Components: ... (A forked, metal rod ... attuned to a particular plane of existence)
It seems there are no universal symbols.
The Manual of the Planes from 3.5 edition includes info on Astral Color Pools on page 48:
There can be permanent portals between various planes and the Astral Plane. Outsiders that otherwise lack planetraveling abilities use these portals to get to the Astral Plane.
A number of openings known as color pools connect the Astral Plane to other planes. Color pools are irregular disks of a particular color floating in the vastness of the Astral Plane. The color of the pool tells the astral traveler what plane is on the other end of the color pool.
There is a parallel for the Ethereal Plane, too (as per page 56:
Shimmering curtains connect the Ethereal Plane to various Inner and Outer Planes. Just like portals, ethereal curtains create conduits through the Astral Plane. While they can be detected from the Material Plane (with a true seeing spell, for example), ethereal curtains can be entered only from the Ethereal Plane.
Ethereal curtains function like the color pools of the Astral Plane, but they always turn travelers solid when they reach the destination plane
This suggests there is a color theme related to various planes (or, at least, their connecting curtains/pools if not the planes themselves) but as for a specific logo identity or brand for each plane, there is no such indication. All the illustrations are used to try and map out the conceptual relationship of their positions and connections and I could not find where any specific graphic mark is mentioned.
Going further back, to the Planeswalker's Handbook from 2nd edition, we see that the planes are represented thematically.
There is an illustration on Page 7 of the Planeswalker's Handbook that shows a few sketches representing the various planes but there is no text accompanying text confirming or describing the illustration represents anything other than one person/character's choice of representation:
On page 105 of the TSR supplement Planes of Chaos, we find the elements (not the planes) represented thusly:
There are a ton of glyphs here but it's critical to note that this illustration pertains not to the elemental planes but to the elements themselves. The illustration is used in conjunction with the description of how the gods, planes, and elements are intertwined so it's conceivable that some of the glyphs would be used to refer to both the element and its corresponding plane.
Here it's worth pointing out that the Planes of Chaos approaches the lore from the Norse mythology so the symbols it features would not be used by, say, the denizens of a given plane or, say, elves who use a different script.
It then seems to me that, aside from a potential color code given by their connections, representing the planes is left to the imagination of whoever is referencing them and is no doubt informed by that individual's culture. Based on the examples above, though, it would seem that certain general imagery (eg flames representing the plane of fire) is likely common.
Best Answer
Though the Feywild might generally be depicted as a wondrous place full of life and vibrant colours while the Shadowfell a dark, dismal place of shadow and death, this hardly means they are (meant to be) inherently good and evil.
The TL;DR version is simply that evil certainly resides in the Feywild and good certainly resides in the Shadowfell.
The Feywild
The Feywild is home to many malevolent and typically evil beings. Hags, goblins, orges, giants, werewolves, blights... You name it. The 4e Heroes of the Feywild (HotF) suppliment even states:
While there may not be a lot of information about the Feywild in 5e there is:
There's plenty of evidence that can be found in the 4e books Manual of the Planes and HotF and the 5e DMG to suggest that the Feywild is certainly not full of only good creatures.
The Shadowfell
There seems to be less direct evidence that there's good in the Shadowfell but one quote in 4e's The Shadowfell - Gloomwrought and Beyond, I think, strongly suggests that even the Shadowfell is not entirely full of evil beings.
Evil may be abundant but it is never stated that only evil beings ever reside in the Shadowfell.
The Manual of the Planes also states:
Much like the natural world there is both good and evil.