[RPG] Can Mordenkainen’s Faithful Hound be made mobile by casting it on a mobile surface

dnd-5espellstargeting

The description of the Mordenkainen's faithful hound spell says, in part:

You conjure a phantom watchdog in an unoccupied space that you can see within range, where it remains for the duration, until you dismiss it as an action, or until you move more than 100 feet away from it.

If I were to cast Mordenkainen's faithful hound to conjure the hound on a wagon, or on Tenser's floating disk, would the hound then be able to follow me around and remain active for it's 8 hour duration?

Best Answer

A surface isn't good enough, it's only mobile if you cast it on a mobile space

The spell neither requires nor interacts with surfaces; you can cast the spell in the formless void of the Plane of Air or 20 feet off a cliff or 200 feet under water in the middle of the ocean, it makes no difference.

Spaces are, however, mobile. Many settings include a planetary cosmology, for example, so the spaces one mostly deals with orbit the setting's Sun or Suns much like a point on the surface of the Earth. Moreover, large vehicles like sailing ships or spacecraft are often mapped out with spaces corresponding to the vehicle rather than the 'ground'. The hound would move along with both kinds of moving spaces just fine.

While there's no way Tenser's floating disk gets its own spaces rather than occupying some/one, a wagon might be big enough to get spaces, though it's unlikely. If it did, this plan could almost work, but it doesn't let the hound change spaces so as soon you moved to a situation where that vehicle was supposed to be following you around (i.e. you aren't in the vehicle; it isn't serving as a location) it should occupy rather than have spaces, and the spell would no longer work the way you wanted (though what actually happens in such a case, much like what happens if the grid alignment changes between scenes with a more traditional space, is not specified in the rules).