[RPG] Can the Heat Metal spell target a set of Dragon Scale Mail made from metallic dragon scales

armordnd-5emagic-itemsspells

The heat metal spell can target "a manufactured metal object", including "a suit of heavy or medium metal armor".

A suit of Dragon Scale Mail is clearly a manufactured object, but if it's made from metallic dragon scales, is it metal, and thus a valid target? Are bronze dragon scales actually made of bronze, or are they just colored like that?

I'm just assuming chromatic dragon scales are inarguably organic.

Best Answer

Probably not.

There is no strong reason to believe that metallic dragon scales are actually made of metal rather than just colored that way. In the absence of a specific statement that dragon scales are in fact made out of the metals they resemble, the default position should be that they're no more metal than red or white dragon scales are.

Metallic coloration is relatively common in real-life fish, insects, and even some reptiles*; and the Monster Manual sections for the different metallic dragons often talk about how the dragon's scales start out dull as a wyrmling and only develop a metallic sheen after many decades or centuries of life. This slow change suggests it's mere coloration.

In terms of older editions, the Draconomicon from D&D 3.5 is explicit about what dragon scales are made of:

Unlike a crocodile, however, a dragon has hundreds of hard, durable scales covering its body. A dragon's scales are keratinous, like its spines. [...] The scales are much harder and less flexible than the spines, with a resistance to blows that exceeds that of steel. - (Draconomicon, p.7)

(Note that 'spines' here is referring to pointed projections or spikes, not the dragon's vertebra.)

Keratins are a class of tough, flexible proteins that make up hair, fingernails, claws, beaks, horns, hooves, and turtle shells -- pretty much any hard surface on an animal that isn't teeth or bones. No mention is made of metals being part of a dragon's scales, whether chromatic or metallic.

*The silvery color associated with fish scales and some insects is actually crystals of the amino acid guanine, a completely non-metallic substance!