[RPG] Can the Telekinesis spell be used to manipulate liquids

dnd-5espellstargeting

The description of the telekinesis spell in the PHB states, under the "Object" section of the spell:

You can try to move an object that weighs up to 1,000 pounds.

[…]

You can exert fine control on objects with your telekinetic grip, such as manipulating a simple tool, opening a door or a container, stowing or retrieving an item from an open container, or pouring the contents from a vial.

For reference, the definition of "object" is:

  1. a material thing that can be seen and touched.

The answers to the question What is considered an object? seem to imply that any material that is inanimate is an object. However, the use of 'object' does not jibe well with what I typically consider to be an object, as I would say that an object needs to be discernible from its surroundings, something you can pick up and manipulate.

Is uncontained liquid (like a puddle of water) considered an object? Can it be controlled with telekinesis?

Best Answer

I would say that liquids are not supposed to be objects in the context of this spell. Let me give my explanation:

The DMG's description of objects defines them as follows (p. 246):

For the purpose of these rules, an object is a discrete, inanimate item like a window, door, sword, book, table, chair, or stone, not a building or a vehicle that is composed of many other objects.

The spell affects objects so you need to see if a liquid fits into the above category. All the examples above are all solids, no liquid examples are given and the differentiation of discrete (single piece) is made; it is hard to describe a liquid as being a discrete single piece entity. DMG then goes on to describe assigning AC and HP to objects, this is not something I would assign to a liquid. There is no definition of liquids in the DMG that I can find (magical potions being liquids but no liquids as such).

Bearing in mind that if you hand-wavium said "yes" to telekinesis then you will have to justify mage hand (which can also manipulate objects) and since that is a cantrip I wish you the best of luck!