If you true polymorph an object into a creature, and concentrate until the effect is indefinite, does the pseudo-creature become a valid target for true resurrection?
As I understand, it would be a complicated living, breathing, thinking, construct, until the spell maintaining it expires, but true resurrection is able to create/renew the body of a creature, that a willing soul can return to.
Basically:
- True Polymorph an object into a (sentient/sapient?) creature.
- Creature is named
- Creature is destroyed prior to becoming permanent by disintegration, leaving no remains to know it reverted back to an object.
- Someone attempts true resurrection, not knowing about the true polymorph, or maybe being super-optimistic. What would the end result be? Nothing? A comatose/soulless body? Pinnochio becomes a real boy?
As true resurrection makes specific mention of the creature's soul, what happens?
Best Answer
Given that you specifically said it's killed before becoming permanent, it depends on if you're using the original Rules as Intended or if you're going with the optional rule from Xanathar's Guide to Everything.
According to this QA if you cast a spell without a valid target (which the True Polymorphed object would be in this case) then the spell slot is not consumed and nothing happens. To summarize Jeremy Crawford's statements in the Sage Advice segment one of the Dragon Talk podcasts here (specifically at about 13:12 for ~7.5 minutes), "illegal targeting" is a gap in the written rules (as of the date of the podcast) and it's mostly open to DMs to choose how to handle it.
The optional rules in Xanathar's state that you DO in fact use the spell slot.
We know that the creature would revert to an object when it reaches 0 HP as True Polymorph specifically states
To illustrate with an order of events:
She kills whatever killed him and then, being overly optimistic, casts TR and given lack of a body says his name
Here's where it gets tricky. One of two things happens but more or less share the same end result of the couch-goblin not being resurrected.
Either A you go by the original RAI and spend an hour casting the spell and she says Greg and then nothing happens.
Or B you go with Xanathar's rule which results in you spending an hour casting the spell, you say Greg at the end and you expend the slot (and I assume the 25k gold worth of diamonds and holy water).
Whichever of the above happens, Greg died and turned back into an object the second his HP hit 0 making him not a valid target.