[RPG] Can trinkets created by the Prestidigitation cantrip substitute material components

cantripsdnd-5espell-componentsspellcastingspells

The prestidigitation cantrip (SRD V5.1, p. 170) allows the caster to create a number of magical effects, one of which is:

You create a non-magical trinket or an illusory image that can fit in
your hand and that lasts until the end of your next turn.

Our group has had all our items taken away, including component pouches and arcane focuses. Certain materials definitely seem like something prestidigitation can make as a trinket such as a magnifying glass.

Assuming the material is cheap (no cost stated) and is not consumed by the spell, can prestidigitation make the material components as trinkets? Even if the person casting it can't use it (since they've used their turn) can another character hold and use it?

Best Answer

Up to the DM

"Trinket" is not a well defined term and thus what prestidigitation can or cannot summon is left up to the DM.

There is no mention of magically summoned components in the general rules (PHB 203). Some spells specifically rule out the use of what they create as components (like creation, PHB 229). This seems to suggest that it is generally ok to do this. Your DM could still reasonably rule otherwise.