[RPG] Can you take the Attack action when not in range of an enethe

actionsattackbardclass-featurednd-5e

Can you take the Attack action without attacking, just to get any side benefits?

For example, Blade Flourish says:

Whenever you take the Attack action on your turn, your walking speed increases by 10 feet until the end of the turn […]

In all examples the bard has a speed of 30 feet and does not have Extra Attack.

First relevant scenario:

The Bard and the enemy is 40 ft apart. If the Bard can take Attack action before spending all 30 ft movement, then he can reach the enemy and attack them with the added extra movement. If not, the Bard and the enemy are now 10 ft apart.

Second relevant scenario:

There is an enemy around the corner. The Bard might or might not know there is an enemy there. With the added movement from Blade Flourish, he will be able to walk around the corner and attack the enemy.

Third relevant scenario:

Same as second scenario, but he will only be able to walk around the corner without being able to attack. He does not know if he can reach to attack the enemy at the end of the turn.

Is taking Attack action allowed without being able to make an attack?

Best Answer

You can't take the Attack action if your target isn't in range

When you take the Attack action you must immediately make an attack

When you take the Attack action you must immediately make an attack against a valid target.

As Jeremy Crawford has said, there is no gap between taking the Attack action and the attack that results from said action.

When you take an action, the action happens. There is no abstract "take an action" step that takes place before the action itself.

If you "take" the Attack action and don't attack, then you have not taken the action. The action and the resulting attack are one and the same.

You must pick a target as soon as you take the Attack action

Under the rules in the PHB under "Making an Attack" it lists the steps one must go through in order to perform an attack.

1. Choose a target. Pick a target within your attack's range: a creature, an object, or a location.

So, since the enemy is too far away to hit with your melee weapon you cannot choose them as a target for your Attack. However, if you didn't care about being able to attack the enemy, you could attack an object or a location that is within range and that would still be considered an attack for the purposes of Blade Flourish.

After you have completed your Attack, you can move (with extra movement)

No matter what you choose to attack, you can now move with whatever movement you have left plus 10 feet of bonus movement from Blade Flourish.

It is important to note that also that rules only allow you to move during an Attack action if you have multiple attacks. In that specific case, it only allows you to move between the attacks, but not before the first attack. No rule allows someone to move during an Attack action before the first attack.

However, if you are only able to make one attack per turn, then you just used your only attack on an object (for example) which gives you enough movement to reach them, but you have no attacks left to attack them with.

Scenario 1

The Bard can take the attack action to attack a rock nearby. After the attack completes, they can move 40 feet and be within melee range of the enemy. However, since they have already spent their Attack, they cannot attack the enemy this turn.

Scenario 2 & 3

As far as I can tell both of these are exactly the same for the rules that are relevant to Blade Flourish.

The Bard does not get extra movement unless they take the Attack action first. Since the enemy has total cover against the Bard, the Bard cannot attack them from their current position. They can attack an object or something and that will give them extra movement just like Scenario 1.

However, why not just use the Bard's normal movement to go around the corner? Once you see the enemy you can attack them if you are within range. If you attack the enemy (instead of an object/location) then you get the benefits of the extra movement and the extra flourishes the result when you hit a creature.

If the enemy more than 30 feet away however, then the Bard will have to choose between using their Attack to get the bonus movement (and not be able to attack the enemy) or if they want to take another action.

If all you want is extra movement, just use Dash

If you are already spending an action to gain movement and already losing your attack, then you should just take the Dash action and get a lot more movement from that spent action.

Really the true benefit from Blade Flourish comes from when you actually have something within your movement/range that you want to Attack and you get the movement as a bonus to that Attack. It doesn't seem to have much use as an ends to gain more movement when there is already an mechanic made for that very purpose.